I love time travel and I love Scottish highland stories.
With that being said, I must add that I enjoyed this series from USA Today's Bestselling Author, Bethany Claire. Morna, a witch
from the 17th century went forward in time to provide her family
assistance from the future. Morna’s goal is to prevent a tragedy that would
have killed her whole clan as well as aiding her male relatives in finding
love. My favorites were books 1 and 3.
"Love Beyond Time," Book 1, is Bri’s story. 21st century Bri trades
places with her look-a-like from the 17th century. There is a struggle
on both sides of time. Each trying to return to their own time (external
struggle) and the “I don’t want to go, but I don’t want to be selfish” element
(internal struggle). There is also the element of danger; no story is complete
without a villain.
"Love Beyond Reason," Book 2, wasn’t as exciting, but still good nonetheless. The
villain from book 1 left behind a mess for book 2 to clean up. Book 2's villain
sprouts out of this mess. It focuses on the 17th century
look-a-like, Blaire. There is more time travel and some twists. Bri’s friend,
Mitsy, from the 21st century is introduced. There is villain on
villain betrayal. A clan shows its lack of loyalty and Blaire finally gets her
guy. The most interesting part is the villain on villain betrayal and the
hiccup in the match making department.
There is also a book 2.5 that tells Adele's, Bri's mom,
story. I thought Adele would fall for Blaire’s dad, but the closer husband
allows her to be closer to Bri. This is the one book that I did not read. It also
had good reviews so don’t make my same mistake I did, check it out.
"Love Beyond Hope," Book 3, is awesome. It tells Mitsy’s story and her journey to
the past. I love her character. The villain in this story is unsuspected and
the author does a good job at not giving it away too early. It features a
brother who is wrongly accused, a hardened heart that is softened and friends
who are reunited. In the end, Mitsy’s new brother-in-law uses her trip back to the
21st century to seek medical assistance which then leads to book 4.
"In Due Time," Book 4.5, tells Jeffery’s story. Jeffery is Cooper’s dad. Confused
yet? As I was reading book 4, I was curious as to how that would play out. I
don’t want to give too much away, but Cooper gets to enjoy both his dad and
step-dad in the 17th century. If you want to know the details…read
the book. Cooper, as insightful as ever, feels that his dad is lonely and seeks
help from Morna. As a result, both Cooper’s aunt and her best friend end up in the
17th century as well. A short novella to fill in the gaps as we
await book 5.
What I didn’t like about this series is the lack of
explanation for the 21st century arrivals. While Bri’s story might
fly, that doesn’t explain Adele or the presence of anyone else. By
the end of book 4.5, there are 9 people spread between 2 clans who all come
from the 21st century. It’s unrealistic for anyone to believe the story of them being from "far away."
My only other complaint would be the character development
of Eoghanan. In book 3, I pictured him as being a smaller, more fragile,
studious-like person, although, it states that he is taller than his
brother. Book 4 fully develops his character for me. Eoghanan gained body and
strength in my imagination; His character developed both physically and
emotionally between the two books. I saw the character traits from book 3 merge
with the man in book 4; meaning that his character development was lacking in
book 3 and more developed in book 4 in my opinion.
Overall, a good series! I would definitely recommend to my
time travel and/or romance fans. They may have had unrealistic explanations for
their presence in the 17th century, but they were definitely
entertaining.
Pictures copied from: http://www.bethanyclaire.com/love-beyond-time.php
Book descriptions can be found here also.